The Best and Worst of 2011 Music
January 3, 2012
The year 2011 was quite a year musically. It seems everybody and their mother was making music — even Dr. House and the dog from Family Guy released their own albums. But the music wasn’t all for the dogs. Here are my awards for the best and worst of 2011 (and everything inbetween).
BEST CHRISTIAN ALBUM – Switchfoot’s Vice Verses. I’ve been hard on Switchfoot ever since they severed ties with Columbia Records in 2007 and tried to do the hip indie thing. This album makes up for all that junk that followed their last truly good album, Nothing Is Sound. Every single track is awesome. From fist-pumping adrenaline to deep, somber reflection, this album is filled with awesomesauce.
BEST SECULAR ALBUM – Coldplay’s Mylo Xyloto. The lush musical textures surrounding “Paradise” and “Every Teardrop Is A Waterfall” are paradise to my ears. Too bad every track isn’t as good as those two. Still, Coldplay lands my top pick for 2011′s secular album of the year. First runner up in 2011 is Adele, who proves it doesn’t take any gimmicks, just raw talent, to be a musical success.
BEST SONG – “Pumped Up Kicks.” Many of this year’s hottest acts were characterized by their throwback to classic sounds (Bruno Mars, Adele, etc.), and who better captured that than Foster the People? I like the way this song takes you inside the life and mindset of a troubled character. The only way we can start to turn the tide in senseless violence is to begin to understand the mindset of those that commit these atrocities.
UP AND COMING AWARD - Royal Tailor (“Hold Me Together”), The Afters (“Light Up The Sky”) and Chris August (“Starry Night”). If these guys are showing us what’s coming up in Christian music, I’m excited!!!
COOLEST BAND NAMES - Anthem Lights and The City Harmonic. I have no idea what they sound like, but I’m digging the names!
COUNTRY SONG OF THE YEAR – Jason Aldean’s “Dirt Road Anthem.” I never thought the rap/sing combo could work in a country song, but it did, and I love it! Stripping the verses down to primarily rhythmic changes allows the choruses to add on melodic changes and elevate the song. It’s such a good formula that regular singers are starting to rap during verses (Jason Aldean, Mat Kearney, etc.), and rappers are pairing with singers to sing the choruses.
AWESOMEST COUNTRY GROUP - Lady Antebellum. They truly owned the night in 2011 with yet another hit album, Own The Night. If I sold my soul to the devil for anything, it would be to sing like that guy from Lady A. Wait, there’s two guys? No, not that one. The other one.
BUSIEST SINGER AWARD – Rihanna. Search iTunes for Rihanna. Find a song she’s not in. I dare you.
NOT TAKING YOURSELF TOO SERIOUSLY AWARD - LMFAO’S Sorry for Party Rocking. How can you not smile when you listen to the crazy lyrics. And the synth-driven, sonically maximized sound exemplifies the ear candy we came to love in 2012. First runner-up goes to Nicki Minaj’s Pink Friday.
COOLEST SONG ABOUT FLORIDA AWARD – Lady Gaga’s “You And I.” So, one day, I’m listening to the radio and hear Lady Gaga singing about how much she loves Florida. But when I buy the album, I realize she’s been cheating on me with Nebraska. Then, I find out she recorded different versions for radio stations in all kinds of different states, and now I just feel so dirty…
MOST CREATIVE DUDE AWARD – David Crowder. The DC*B never disappoints, and their musical creativity seems to know no end (though it will end after their final album is released on Jan. 10, 2012). Just when you think they’ve done it all, here comes a Christmas album filled with techno, bluegrass and everything in between!
BEST KEPT SECRET - 10,000 Reasons by Matt Redman. Speaking of unrealized potential, Matt Redman’s new live worship album should have generated more buzz than it did. It’s easily the best worship album of the year. And Nathan Nockels’s producing is always a key part of that winning recipe. I was in the crowd at the recording of this album, so be sure to listen for my out of tune voice in the background!
STILL GOING STRONG AWARD - Passion Worship Band. After all these years, Passion is still churning out relevant worship music. Their latest, Here For You, doesn’t disappoint.
BAD SONG SELECTION AWARD - Glee Cast. Compared to their bestsellers that topped the iTunes charts in their first season, now they’re just floundering. Why are they having these kids sing all these old songs. Do they really want to secure the grandma demographic? And what’s up with the heavy-handed political and moral overtones in their scripts now?
BAD STUDIO SELECTION AWARD - Kristian Stanfill. I’ve been a fan of Kristian before anyone knew him. From the first time I heard him at North Point Community Church, I knew he was going places. Shortly after, he was at Passion. Shortly after, he was signed by Louie Giglio’s record label. It’s too bad that they seem to be skimping on the recording budget for him. Chris Tomlin gets mixed and mastered like the pro he is. But Kristian’s albums always seem tinny and irritating. I like the production value much better on his old indie record. Let’s get this guy into a better studio in 2012!
UNREALIZED POTENTIAL AWARD – Javier Colon, the winner of NBC’s The Voice. This guy can sing like an angel. He’s been signed with a record label before. Then he went indie. Now he’s on a label again. But he still hasn’t found the right formula for success, even with all the recent notoriety. He just needs the right producer to work with and some decent distribution. I sure hope he finds it in 2012.
ONE TO WATCH AWARD - Elenowen. Another talent brought to light through NBC’s The Voice, and I can’t wait for their next project!
COMING INTO HER OWN AWARD – Laura Story. Thanks to her breakout hit, “Blessings,” Laura Story is on the map in a big way. You’ve heard her songwriting before (“Indescribably,” for instance), and now you get to hear her own voice sing her great lyrics. She’s one of the best, if not the best, Christian songwriter out there today, so I’m glad the spotlight is finally landing on her!
STILL DON’T GET IT AWARD – Gungor and Bon Iver and John Marc McMillan and Florence + The Machine and Mumford and Sons and Toby Keith’s “Red Solo Cup.” Am I missing something here?
BARELY HANGING ON AWARD – Hillsong, Kelly Clarkson, David Cook, Owl City. I hope they make it, but 2011 wasn’t the best year for any of the above.
PUT A FORK IN IT AWARD – Smitty (Glory), SCC (Re:creation) and Point Of Grace (Winter Wonderland). They all proved that it’s time to put the mic down and step away slowly…
WORST COVER BAND AWARD – Newsboys, for giving us yet another cover (“God’s Not Dead”). And, let’s be honest. You’re not Newsboys anymore. You’re Tait. And Peter Furler is not Peter Furler. He’s Newsboys.
THE “MEH” AWARD – Shawn McDonald, Josh Wilson, Mandisa, Francesca Battistelli, Shane & Shane, Kirk Franklin and Phil Wickham. Yawn…
MOST HERETICAL LYRIC AWARD – MIKESCHAIR’s “Someone Worth Dying For.” I was a sinner — not someone who, in and of myself, deserved anything. That’s what makes God’s grace so amazing — I was not worth dying for, but He saved me anyway, to the praise of the glorious riches of His grace.
That’s about it! What makes your top list for 2011?


Thanks to AT&T’s horrific service, for the past week I haven’t been able to use my iPhone as… well, a phone. It’s pretty much an iPod Touch right now, but that’s OK because I have a backup plan – Voice-over-Internet Protocol (VoIP).
Finally, someone is going to do the cloud right! For instance, once you purchase a track on iTunes, you can re-download it easily to any of your devices at any time. Contrast this with Amazon’s restrictions of downloading. I recently purchased an MP3 album from Amazon.com, and the download locked up. I tried to restart it, but found that Amazon only allowed me one download. I had to call customer support to get another shot at it. I was on hold with foreigners for almost two hours trying to get that stupid album to download. Wow. Thankfully, Apple is setting a new standard that it’s OK to allow customers to re-download purchased tracks. (Now, if we could just get Apple to match Amazon’s pricing on MP3′s…)
At the first sign of spring, I grab my camera and drive around, looking for the perfect shot. As I drove my family back from Pipestem State Park last weekend, the journey took twice as long as usual because I was constantly pulling over to take a picture. I’m sure it drove them crazy, but it was almost a healing experience for me. Having barely survived a crazy, crazy week, it was a 180-degree flip to take things slowly on purpose.
Maybe we should take this mindset with us the rest of the year too. What would it look like if we looked for the good all around us? In the office? In the airport? In the checkout line? What if every mundane minute of our lives could be turned into a search for beauty? God’s hidden it all around us, tucked away in the personalities of our co-workers and the faces of strangers on the sidewalk.
It’s easy to miss the elegant simplicity of Apple’s design philosophy because it’s so transparent — things just work. This is true of both hardware and software. For example, the iPad is lightweight and balanced in your hand – something you might not notice until you pick up a Motorola Zoom and see what a heavy, unbalanced tablet feels like. Similarly, the software’s design is also transparent. You may not notice how easy the operating system is to use until you try to figure out how to use a Microsoft or Android device.




One of the “benefits” of the rental car is Sirius XM satellite radio. You can’t beat the selection of music — my favorite is Hits 1. And everybody is raving about the digital quality… that is, everybody but me.


